A win for the ‘Gig economy?’- UK Supreme court rules Deliveroo Riders are not employees

22 November 2023

After 7 years of litigation, the ruling is clear. Deliveroo riders cannot be recognised as employees with five judges claiming the contracts between riders and the company did not constitute an “employment relationship” because riders were able to use another person to cover their deliveries without Deliveroo’s involvement plus riders are free to reject offers of work, to make themselves unavailable and to undertake work for competitors.

Which, as many of us know, isn’t a regular employee and employer relationship

So what does this mean?

The Independent Workers’ Union of Great Britain (IWGB), which has the largest membership of app-based couriers in the UK, had fought the case to place key protections for gig-workers and allow for representation by trade unions for collective bargaining.

Collective bargaining allows negotiation between employers and a group of employees aimed at agreements to regulate working salaries, working conditions, benefits, and other aspects of workers’ compensation and rights for workers.

The IWGB described the ruling as a “disappointment”. “We cannot accept that thousands of riders should be working without key protections . . . and we will continue to make that case using all avenues available to us,” it said.

Is it a bleak decision? Or a freeing one? And what does it mean to freelancers, if anything?

What about Employers…

This decision is one that will be welcomed by employers who are hiring staff the way Deliveroo have and follow a similar model. What can you take away from this?

First, it is key to focus your understanding on the reasoning behind the courts findings.

We see lots of employers who still don’t work in the ‘Deliveroo’ way but claim they are using freelancers! What’s important in light of this decision is to be aware of all the factors and understand when your staff are deemed employees and if you fall in the right side of law just like Deliveroo did.

Not sure or want to be extra cautious? Get in touch today with our employment team and we can chat about your business: https://www.acumenbusinesslaw.co.uk/contact/

Get in touch

Related Stories

News

Key differences between Section 8 and Section 21 Notices

As a landlord, you have two primary tools for ending a tenancy under the Housing Act 1988: Section 21 and Section 8, each serving different purposes. Understanding when to use these notices can help resolve issues such as unpaid rent, property disrepair, or the need to reclaim the property for redevelopment.

News

Retail Giant, Tesco, cannot fire and rehire… Can you?

The Supreme Court has ruled that Tesco cannot fire and rehire employees on less favourable terms. The decision, made in Tesco Stores v Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers [2024] UKSC 28, blocks Tesco from dismissing staff to reoffer them positions without their enhanced pay. The Court, led by Lord Reed, found that allowing such dismissals would undermine the original contract’s purpose. While this ruling enforces contractual intentions, it does not eliminate the fire-and-rehire practice, which can still be used legally if done fairly.

News

Changes incoming: The Autumn Budget

With October just around the corner, the autumn budget is fast approaching, and many business owners are now considering how potential changes might impact their operations. In some cases, this uncertainty has even prompted business owners to explore selling or exiting their businesses. To help you navigate this uncertain time, we’ll break down the key issues and how they could affect you.

Check us out on social